
The United States Supreme Court is an inteÂgral part of the govÂernÂment of this counÂtry, the third leg that holds the triÂpod steady.
Over the years — even decades — disÂputes have arisen over the powÂer that nine indiÂvidÂuÂals hold when comÂpared to the diluÂtion of powÂer vestÂed among 535 memÂbers of Congress.
Of course, the Court was not always nine memÂbers. Early after its forÂmaÂtion, it vacÂilÂlatÂed from as many as 10 to as few as five. In 1869 the numÂber was set at nine, where it has remained, although there have been a few attempts to increase the numÂber, most specifÂiÂcalÂly under the tenure of Franklin Roosevelt who was frusÂtratÂed by a court that conÂtinÂuÂalÂly thwartÂed his New Deal legislation.
A few interÂestÂing hisÂtorÂiÂcal tidÂbits about the Court: George Washington made the most appointÂments because the Court was formed durÂing his presÂiÂdenÂcy. He appointÂed ten. Franklin Roosevelt appointÂed eight, Andrew Jackson appointÂed six, and Lincoln, Grant, Taft and Eisenhower each appointÂed five. Zachary Taylor, Andrew Johnson, William Henry Harrison and Jimmy Carter were all denied any appointments.
Prior to 1967, 67 jusÂtices of the 116 who have served, were conÂfirmed by voice vote, none afterÂwards, and late in the twenÂtiÂeth cenÂtuÂry Congressional approval for jusÂtices became more conÂtentious. In 1991 Clarence Thomas was conÂfirmed by a vote of 52–48. After 2005, the highÂest approval was for John Roberts at 78% and the lowÂest for Kavanaugh at 51%.
According to a Brennan Center for Justice study there has been a rather drasÂtic change in the makeÂup of the court since 1966. Prior to that year, the mediÂan term for a Supreme Court jusÂtice was 15.3 years. Obviously, some jusÂtices served a good deal longer, such as Justice William O. Douglas who served 39.9 years until 1980.
Following 1966 every sinÂgle jusÂtice has served over 15 years, exceptÂing the curÂrentÂly servÂing Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, Ketanji Brown Jackson, Amy Coney Barrett. Clarence Thomas is approachÂing 35 years on the bench.
After 1966, the mediÂan term for a jusÂtice rose to 25.7 years.
Never miss a thing with our FREE weekly newsletter.
The point of all this is that the time has long passed for conÂsidÂerÂaÂtion to be givÂen to makÂing terms on the Supreme Court subÂject to limÂiÂtaÂtions. There is conÂsidÂerÂable curÂrent supÂport for limÂitÂing the terms to 18 years, a periÂod by which a jusÂtice would not be subÂjectÂed to the vagaries of changÂing politÂiÂcal conÂsidÂerÂaÂtions. My perÂsonÂal prefÂerÂence is for a term of 15 years, along with stipÂuÂlaÂtions regardÂing age limitations.
It’s so odd that the Constitution stipÂuÂlates the minÂiÂmum age for presÂiÂdent, senÂaÂtor and repÂreÂsenÂtaÂtive but not for a Supreme Court jusÂtice, and no upper age limÂits are notÂed for any of these offices. In fact, an appointee to the Supreme Court is not even required to be a licensed attorÂney. Forty-sevÂen of the jusÂtices were not licensed attorÂneys but at least received some legal eduÂcaÂtion. It was not uncomÂmon in the 19th cenÂtuÂry for attorÂneys to be self-taught and to pracÂtice withÂout law school degrees.
Article III, Section 1 of the Constitution simÂply states that jusÂtices “shall hold their Offices durÂing good Behaviour” and while hisÂtoÂry has perÂmitÂted jusÂtices to remain in office indefÂiÂniteÂly per this conÂstiÂtuÂtionÂal proÂviÂsion, it has recentÂly been sugÂgestÂed that terms on the Supreme Court could be adjustÂed withÂout resort to a conÂstiÂtuÂtionÂal amendÂment by passÂing legÂisÂlaÂtion statÂing that a Supreme Court jusÂtice shall be moved to a posiÂtion in a lowÂer court, and still conÂtinÂue “durÂing good behaviour.”
Today’s Supreme Court has the lowÂest approval ratÂing, perÂhaps in its entire hisÂtoÂry, even among memÂbers of Congress so it seems that the time is right to make changes to the court.

