Why the Supreme Court needs term limits

Justices now serve longer than ever, and support for term limits keeps growing

|

Estimated time to read:

3–4 minutes
The current U.S. Supreme Court.
The cur­rent U.S. Supreme Court. (Fred Schilling — https://www.supremecourt.gov/about/justices.aspx, Public Domain, Link)

The United States Supreme Court is an inte­gral part of the gov­ern­ment of this coun­try, the third leg that holds the tri­pod steady.

Over the years — even decades — dis­putes have arisen over the pow­er that nine indi­vid­u­als hold when com­pared to the dilu­tion of pow­er vest­ed among 535 mem­bers of Congress.

Of course, the Court was not always nine mem­bers. Early after its for­ma­tion, it vac­il­lat­ed from as many as 10 to as few as five. In 1869 the num­ber was set at nine, where it has remained, although there have been a few attempts to increase the num­ber, most specif­i­cal­ly under the tenure of Franklin Roosevelt who was frus­trat­ed by a court that con­tin­u­al­ly thwart­ed his New Deal legislation.

A few inter­est­ing his­tor­i­cal tid­bits about the Court: George Washington made the most appoint­ments because the Court was formed dur­ing his pres­i­den­cy. He appoint­ed ten. Franklin Roosevelt appoint­ed eight, Andrew Jackson appoint­ed six, and Lincoln, Grant, Taft and Eisenhower each appoint­ed five. Zachary Taylor, Andrew Johnson, William Henry Harrison and Jimmy Carter were all denied any appointments.

Prior to 1967, 67 jus­tices of the 116 who have served, were con­firmed by voice vote, none after­wards, and late in the twen­ti­eth cen­tu­ry Congressional approval for jus­tices became more con­tentious. In 1991 Clarence Thomas was con­firmed by a vote of 52–48. After 2005, the high­est approval was for John Roberts at 78% and the low­est for Kavanaugh at 51%.

According to a Brennan Center for Justice study there has been a rather dras­tic change in the make­up of the court since 1966. Prior to that year, the medi­an term for a Supreme Court jus­tice was 15.3 years. Obviously, some jus­tices served a good deal longer, such as Justice William O. Douglas who served 39.9 years until 1980.

Following 1966 every sin­gle jus­tice has served over 15 years, except­ing the cur­rent­ly serv­ing Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, Ketanji Brown Jackson, Amy Coney Barrett. Clarence Thomas is approach­ing 35 years on the bench.

After 1966, the medi­an term for a jus­tice rose to 25.7 years.

Never miss a thing with our FREE weekly newsletter.

The point of all this is that the time has long passed for con­sid­er­a­tion to be giv­en to mak­ing terms on the Supreme Court sub­ject to lim­i­ta­tions. There is con­sid­er­able cur­rent sup­port for lim­it­ing the terms to 18 years, a peri­od by which a jus­tice would not be sub­ject­ed to the vagaries of chang­ing polit­i­cal con­sid­er­a­tions. My per­son­al pref­er­ence is for a term of 15 years, along with stip­u­la­tions regard­ing age limitations.

It’s so odd that the Constitution stip­u­lates the min­i­mum age for pres­i­dent, sen­a­tor and rep­re­sen­ta­tive but not for a Supreme Court jus­tice, and no upper age lim­its are not­ed for any of these offices. In fact, an appointee to the Supreme Court is not even required to be a licensed attor­ney. Forty-sev­en of the jus­tices were not licensed attor­neys but at least received some legal edu­ca­tion. It was not uncom­mon in the 19th cen­tu­ry for attor­neys to be self-taught and to prac­tice with­out law school degrees.

Article III, Section 1 of the Constitution sim­ply states that jus­tices “shall hold their Offices dur­ing good Behaviour” and while his­to­ry has per­mit­ted jus­tices to remain in office indef­i­nite­ly per this con­sti­tu­tion­al pro­vi­sion, it has recent­ly been sug­gest­ed that terms on the Supreme Court could be adjust­ed with­out resort to a con­sti­tu­tion­al amend­ment by pass­ing leg­is­la­tion stat­ing that a Supreme Court jus­tice shall be moved to a posi­tion in a low­er court, and still con­tin­ue “dur­ing good behaviour.”

Today’s Supreme Court has the low­est approval rat­ing, per­haps in its entire his­to­ry, even among mem­bers of Congress so it seems that the time is right to make changes to the court.

Please share this story!