Why making things keeps us human in the AI age

|

Estimated time to read:

3–5 minutes
Ancient cave paintings in Patagonia, southern Argentina.
Ancient cave paint­ings in Patagonia, south­ern Argentina. (Adobe Stock image)

It hap­pened again. Someone accused me of using AI to write all of my Monday Motivations. I under­stand why peo­ple are ask­ing that ques­tion these days. But words are how I make sense of being human and that’s not some­thing I would outsource. 

What a strange thing to accuse some­one of using a tool to avoid the very human work of think­ing, feel­ing, and mak­ing mean­ing. My writ­ing comes from a life­time of pay­ing atten­tion. The fact that a machine can imi­tate my lan­guage doesn’t make my thoughts any less valuable. 

There is a Latin phrase I love. Homo faber, or humans are mak­ers. We make tools and shel­ters, songs and sto­ries, pots and paint­ings. We carve faces into stone, weave bas­kets from grass, and turn the grief of a bro­ken heart into a poem some­one else will hope­ful­ly read two thou­sand years lat­er and think, Me, too. We have been mak­ing things for as long as we have been human. Perhaps longer, if you count the ochre-stained hands pressed against the walls of caves, reach­ing across tens of thou­sands of years to say I was here. I saw this. I want­ed you to know. 

We were made for this. Not nec­es­sar­i­ly by a god or a grand cos­mic plan, but by the beau­ti­ful acci­dent of being con­scious crea­tures who can imag­ine some­thing that does not yet exist and then bring it into the world. We are the ani­mals who look at a sun­set and want to paint it. Who hear a bird singing and want to sing back. Who gath­er around fires to tell sto­ries, even when the sto­ries are sad, even when the end­ing is uncer­tain, even when we already know how they go. We make things because being alive is an expe­ri­ence so strange and aston­ish­ing and heart­break­ing that some­times the only way to metab­o­lize it is to give it a shape. 

“A machine can gen­er­ate a pic­ture of a woman stand­ing in a field of wild­flow­ers. But it has nev­er stood in a field and felt the par­tic­u­lar ache of being a woman in a world that keeps telling her who to be.”

Erin Skinner Smith

Which is why I find the rise of arti­fi­cial intel­li­gence in the arts so unset­tling. Of course a machine can pro­duce an image or a song or a con­vinc­ing para­graph; humans have always made tech­no­log­i­cal tools that extend our abil­i­ties. The ques­tion is not whether a machine can pro­duce some­thing beau­ti­ful. The ques­tion is what we believe beau­ty is for. 

Art is not mere­ly an object at the end of a pro­duc­tion line. It is the expe­ri­ence of mak­ing it. It is the years of learn­ing to see, the hours of get­ting some­thing wrong, the will­ing­ness to be a begin­ner, the pecu­liar sat­is­fac­tion of find­ing the exact word or col­or or note that brings some­thing into focus. It is the human being who has lived a life, gath­ered its sor­rows and absur­di­ties, and decid­ed to make some­thing from them. 

A machine can gen­er­ate a pic­ture of a woman stand­ing in a field of wild­flow­ers. But it has nev­er stood in a field and felt the par­tic­u­lar ache of being a woman in a world that keeps telling her who to be. It has nev­er watched the light fall across the grass and remem­bered some­one who is gone. It has nev­er been sur­prised by its own capac­i­ty for ten­der­ness. Human made art may not always be tech­ni­cal­ly supe­ri­or, but art is not sim­ply the pro­duc­tion of some­thing worth look­ing at.  

Never miss a thing with our FREE weekly newsletter.

Creation is a way of being in the world. 

When we out­source the mak­ing, we risk los­ing the prac­tice of pay­ing atten­tion, of devel­op­ing a point of view, of dis­cov­er­ing what we think by try­ing to express it. We risk becom­ing con­sumers of beau­ty rather than par­tic­i­pants in its creation. 

And we do not need to be par­tic­u­lar­ly good at mak­ing art for any of this to mat­ter. You do not have to pub­lish the poem, sell the paint­ing, or play the piano beau­ti­ful­ly. I write well, water­col­or poor­ly, play the gui­tar just fine, and tap dance like I’m recov­er­ing from a stroke. It doesn’t mat­ter if my cre­ation is awk­ward, earnest, or lop­sided, as long as it’s entire­ly my own. I’m not com­pet­ing with a machine; I am being a person. 

So go make things that do not need to be opti­mized. Write bad­ly but hon­est­ly. Paint bad­ly but with feel­ing. Plant gar­dens, bake bread, build bird­hous­es, sketch sleep­ing dogs, sing off-key in the kitchen. Make things that are unnec­es­sary by every eco­nom­ic mea­sure and indis­pens­able by every human one. 

We are homo faber. We are the makers. 

Please share this story!