
It’s been an interÂestÂing cenÂtuÂry since the culÂmiÂnaÂtion of the Scopes triÂal, more popÂuÂlarÂly known as the “Monkey Trial.” Actually, it was 101 years ago that the triÂal took place in Dayton, Tennessee in the sumÂmer of 1925.
Briefly, the triÂal was the prosÂeÂcuÂtion of John Scopes, a local high school teacher who had agreed to be a test case of the recentÂly passed Butler Law, which banned teachÂing evoÂluÂtion in pubÂlic schools.
Local busiÂnessÂmen thought a pubÂlic triÂal would bring some notoÂriÂety to the town so they arranged for Clarence Darrow to serve as defense lawyer for Scopes while William Jennings Bryan would be the prosÂeÂcutÂing attorney.
The businessmen’s vision paid off. Thousands came to the town, creÂatÂing a carÂniÂval atmosÂphere and the triÂal was broadÂcast on radio, someÂthing highÂly unusuÂal for the periÂod. The triÂal quickÂly devolved into a debate over evoÂluÂtion, with the fate of Scopes takÂing a backÂground position.
Scopes was found guilty. He did, after all, vioÂlate state law, but the verÂdict of a $100 fine was latÂer overÂturned on a technicality.
All the furor in Dayton must have spurred ongoÂing conÂverÂsaÂtion about evoÂluÂtion since Mississippi passed a simÂiÂlar law in 1926, folÂlowed by Arkansas in 1928. All these laws stayed on the books until 1967 for Tennessee and 1968 for Mississippi and Arkansas.
In more recent years, efforts have conÂtinÂued to require the teachÂing of alterÂnaÂtive creÂation theÂoÂries in the pubÂlic schools. Part of those efforts have cenÂtered around renamÂing these reliÂgion-based proÂposÂals under the title of “creÂationÂism” and “intelÂliÂgent design.”
In 2002, stickÂers were placed on biolÂoÂgy textÂbooks in Georgia instructÂing stuÂdents that evoÂluÂtion was a “theÂoÂry only and not a fact.”
In Kentucky, in 1999 “evoÂluÂtion” in sciÂence curÂricuÂlum guideÂlines was replaced with “change over time.”
In 2001, Senator Rick Santorum (Republican of Pennsylvania) proÂposed an amendÂment to the eduÂcaÂtion fundÂing bill that proÂmotÂed the teachÂing of intelÂliÂgent design.
Perhaps the most well-known attempt to insert anti-evoÂluÂtion theÂoÂries into the pubÂlic classÂrooms was thwartÂed in the case of Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District in Pennsylvania in 2005. Judge John E. Jones issued a 130-page rulÂing that statÂed that intelÂliÂgent design was a reliÂgious theÂoÂry with no sciÂenÂtifÂic basis. Since the school board memÂbers who defendÂed the polÂiÂcy of teachÂing intelÂliÂgent design were all defeatÂed in elecÂtions that year, the case was nevÂer appealed. This was essenÂtialÂly the death knell of intelÂliÂgent design, at least as a subÂject for pubÂlic high school classes.
Today, evoÂluÂtion is taught in every state’s pubÂlic schools and no states require the teachÂing of creÂationÂism — although it may be taught in civics, curÂrent affairs, phiÂlosÂoÂphy, and comÂparÂaÂtive reliÂgion classes.
In a 2019 Gallup poll, 40% of American adults were inclined to the belief that “God creÂatÂed humans in their present form at one time withÂin the last 10,000 years.”
It would be interÂestÂing to see how that belief appears in othÂer counÂtries of the world.
Dayton returned to its small-town simÂplicÂiÂty not long after the triÂal; it sits a short disÂtance off I‑75 and one can visÂit the courÂtÂhouse where the triÂal took place. Interestingly, a statÂue of Bryan was erectÂed at the courÂtÂhouse in 2005, but it was not until 2017 that a simÂiÂlar statÂue of Darrow was erectÂed nearÂby, its $150,000 cost paid by the Freedom From Religion Foundation.
Get the book! "Our Stories, Our Voices: A 5-Year Annioversary Collection."
The movie Inherit the Wind (1960) is a dramaÂtiÂzaÂtion of the triÂal, starÂring Spencer Tracy as Henry Drummond (Darrow) and Frederick March as Matthew Harrison Brady (Bryan). Harry Morgan, whom many rememÂber as Colonel Potter of M*A*S*H, was the preÂsidÂing judge. Gene Kelly plays E.K. Hornbeck (H. L. Mencken, who covÂered the trial).
Some of the diaÂlogue in the movie is actuÂal tesÂtiÂmoÂny from the triÂal, espeÂcialÂly Darrow’s (Spencer Tracy’s) speech about “marchÂing backÂward in time.”
This was a most interÂestÂing periÂod of American hisÂtoÂry and the triÂal was a fasÂciÂnatÂing pinÂpoint in that period.
Excellent readÂing about the triÂal, with actuÂal tranÂscripts from parts of the triÂal, can be found in Monkey Business by Marvin Olasky and John Perry, Keeping the Faith by Brenda Wineapple, The Last Trials of Clarence Darrow by Donald McRae and Summer for the Gods by Edward J. Larson.

