As a real estate agent and broker, Kelley Nisbet is an advocate for private property rights and affordable housing. As a planning and zoning official, she believes in managed growth. And as a small business owner and candidate for county government, she wants to coöperate with partners to achieve responsible spending and revenue growth.
“I think there’s a need for working together — not in a political way, but just working with the other magistrates and the county judge-executive to really push Clark County forward,” Nisbet said in an interview. “We’re in a unique position, and I think the position can only be accentuated by those people, not necessarily like-minded in the way they think, but like-minded in the way that we want our community to be successful, and be safe, and grow.”

Nisbet, 56, was born in Winchester and grew up in Clark County. After attending George Rogers Clark High School for a year, she transferred to Sayre School in Lexington, where she graduated, and then earned bachelor’s degrees in finance and economics at the University of Kentucky.
She has been a licensed real estate agent for Coldwell Banker McMahan in Winchester since 1996, and has served as chair and treasurer of the Realtors Political Action Committee, through which she has worked with lobbyists on legislation.
Nisbet is also in her third year as a board member of the Winchester-Clark County Planning Commission.
She has two children who are in business: a son, Pearce, 26, of Lexington, who is a graduate of Transylvania University, and Elizabeth Ann, 23, a graduate of Western Kentucky University.
Although she was a Democrat until last year, she is running for 2nd District magistrate in the Republican primary against the incumbent and another candidate. It is her first time seeking elected office.
“When you see things you think are not necessarily the best path for the whole community, then you get involved, and that’s where I am now,” she said.
Nisbet said she wants to see a balanced approach to business and residential growth with attention not only to new residents who want to come in, but also to the “current community.”
There is a great need for affordable housing not only in Clark County but also in Kentucky, she said. And as long as the supply is less than the demand, home ownership and rent are going to be expensive. When making decisions, leaders must consider not only new residents but also those already living here, whose homes are likely their biggest investments.
“Probably 80 percent of the people out there are sitting on mortgages with interest rates below five percent. Nobody wants to move off that at this time,” she said.
Officials must consider how actions affect neighbors’ property values, she noted.
Adhering to the city-county comprehensive plan is the key to preserving farmland and the county’s rural and agricultural character while also promoting “smart growth” to meet the community’s needs, she said.
“That plan identifies where the growth is to take place and what that growth should look like,” Nisbet explained. “It’s a delicate balance of development and property rights.”
“Those who fail to plan,” she added, “plan to fail.”
Nisbet said she sees the county’s budget as its biggest challenge, but added that “your biggest challenges” can be “your biggest opportunities.”
Having represented 4,200 small businesses in 38 counties as president of Bluegrass Realtors, she said, is a good background for examining the county’s budget, its successes and shortcomings, and for working with others to resolve issues.
Nisbet said no candidate can honestly say they will lower or raise taxes or spending until they’re in office and can see the situation, but she has done some research. She’s talked with the jailer and is impressed with the way the jail is managed. She is also aware of possible solutions that have been brought forward to improve fire protection and emergency medical services, and thinks they should be considered.
“It’s not about who has the power—the city or the county—it’s about making sure that everyone in Winchester and Clark County is taken care of,” she said.
Nisbet said she wants to see greater accountability in spending and mentioned that “some recent purchases were not appropriate.” Not that they weren’t needed, she said, but “if you purchase things and you don’t have an appraisal and you use all of your cash,” that isn’t how most people would do things personally or professionally, and it isn’t how they should operate in public office.
Whoever wins the Republican primary is almost certain to become the 2nd District magistrate because there is no Democrat in the race.
Never miss a thing with our FREE weekly newsletter.
Asked why she thinks she’s the best of the three candidates in the primary, Nisbet answered: “I bring a skills set to the table of being a small business owner … of being able to negotiate for a living, to compromise,” and make tough but fair decisions.
Also, she said, “I think it’s time for a female magistrate.”
Diversity is important, she said, and there hasn’t been a woman on the Fiscal Court for many years.
“I think it’s time, and I think I can help make a difference on a level that is respectful and coming from a place of knowledge,” Nisbet said. “I look forward to this endeavor. I think it’s the highest honor to be considered to be a civil servant and to give back to the community that has given to you.”
