The stubborn blight of illegal yard signs

Why Winchester needs a stronger, enforceable ordinance to clean up its roadsides

|

Estimated time to read:

2–3 minutes

“What this coun­try needs is a good five‑cent cigar.” 

Thomas Marshall, vice pres­i­dent under Woodrow Wilson

What this com­mu­ni­ty needs is a good, strong, and fair ordi­nance that will per­ma­nent­ly elim­i­nate the ille­gal yard signs that keep appear­ing along our streets and roadways.

I have railed about these signs for years and apol­o­gize for bring­ing it up again. As spring approach­es, yard signs seem to sprout as vora­cious­ly as dan­de­lions, espe­cial­ly at major inter­sec­tions and sub­di­vi­sion entrances.

Despite a rea­son­able and com­pre­hen­sive sign ordi­nance that cov­ers the entire coun­ty, many of its pro­vi­sions are not rou­tine­ly enforced—particularly the pro­hi­bi­tion of non‑governmental signs in pub­lic rights‑of‑way and the require­ment to remove signs from closed businesses.

Some signs are even sta­pled or nailed to wood­en util­i­ty poles. Those poles are pri­vate prop­er­ty, and plac­ing a sign on one is no dif­fer­ent from plac­ing a sign in someone’s yard.

The ordi­nance requires signs from closed busi­ness­es to be removed with­in 45 days (Section 11.7.K), yet many remain for months. Frisch’s and KU are recent examples.

What is trou­bling about the pro­lif­er­a­tion of yard signs is that so many indi­vid­u­als and com­pa­nies are either unaware of the pro­hi­bi­tions or sim­ply ignore them. And the num­ber of peo­ple will­ing to remove ille­gal signs is far out­num­bered by those who want to put them up. Yard sale signs, in par­tic­u­lar, often remain long after the event has ended.

Most recent­ly, a lawn‑care com­pa­ny placed numer­ous signs at var­i­ous inter­sec­tions, includ­ing Colby and McClure Roads—the inter­sec­tion that rou­tine­ly attracts the most signs each year.

Never miss a thing with our FREE weekly newsletter.

Surely the legal coun­sel for the City Commission and Fiscal Court can craft an enforce­able and fair ordi­nance to curb this abuse, per­haps by impos­ing a $25 fine for each ille­gal­ly placed sign. Fines could be assessed against the address of a yard sale or the com­pa­ny named on the sign. To pre­vent a flood of signs, the fine should apply to each indi­vid­ual sign.

Some signs adver­tise wor­thy caus­es, but they too must be sub­ject to the same rules. There are many ways to adver­tise; lit­ter­ing the land­scape with these hideous signs is not one of them.

And to be clear, polit­i­cal signs placed in pub­lic rights‑of‑way are not exempt. We will sure­ly see an abun­dance of them before the November election.

In the meantime—and giv­en the like­li­hood that we will nev­er have an enforce­able ordinance—private cit­i­zens are encour­aged to remove these signs when­ev­er they appear. They are ille­gal and amount to noth­ing more than road­way detritus.

Please share this story!