Centrists deserve credit for Democrats’ sweeping election victory

Moderates won the toughest races nationwide, and Democrats who ignore that lesson risk losing 2028

|

Estimated time to read:

7–10 minutes
Reporter's Notebook

Democrats have defied the odds, gain­ing con­trol of Congress in a his­toric land­slide election.

With con­tests for the last two Senate seats decid­ed this week, the par­ty will begin 2027 with a 56–44 major­i­ty in that cham­ber, as well as a like­ly 260–175 mar­gin in the House of Representatives.

Not only did Democrats take Capitol Hill, but they also now con­trol most of the state leg­is­la­tures and gov­er­nor­ships in the country.

The 2026 midterm reminds me of 1974, when vot­ers repu­di­at­ed Richard Nixon’s cor­rupt, auto­crat­ic admin­is­tra­tion by elect­ing a new gen­er­a­tion of reform-mind­ed Democrats to Congress, and then two years lat­er, putting a Democrat in the White House after eight years of Republican rule.

But I’m also remind­ed of how quick­ly Republicans reversed that rout and how eas­i­ly it could hap­pen again.

Already, Democratic pro­gres­sives are try­ing to snatch defeat from the jaws of vic­to­ry. They want to replace mod­er­ate Chuck Schumer as Senate major­i­ty leader and are encour­ag­ing left­ists Ro Khanna and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez to run for president.

Those two have about the same chance of win­ning the White House as the Los Angeles Chargers or the New York Jets have of win­ning the Super Bowl.

There was no blue wave in Clark County, but Democrats made big gains in Congress and statehouses across the country.
There was no blue wave in Clark County, but Democrats made big gains in Congress and state­hous­es across the country.

True, there was a string of wins by demo­c­ra­t­ic social­ists and social lib­er­als from L.A. to D.C. last week, but what that means is that blue parts of the coun­try got a lit­tle bluer — not that the left won con­verts in red states and districts.

What has been large­ly over­looked by par­ty activists and the media is that in almost every com­pet­i­tive race in the coun­try, it was cen­trists who accom­plished what seemed unlike­ly or even impos­si­ble only a few months ago.

In Kansas, which had not elect­ed a Democrat to the Senate in almost a cen­tu­ry, megachurch pas­tor Adam Hamilton won with 51 per­cent of the vote in a three-way race with a Republican and a Libertarian.

In Texas, Democrat James Talarico won John Cornyn’s U.S. Senate seat, and his par­ty gained House seats. But also, Gina Hinojosa, who dis­tanced her­self from the pro­gres­sive label she once embraced, unseat­ed the Republican gov­er­nor, Greg Abbott, becom­ing the first Democrat to lead the Lone Star State in more than three decades, and in a stun­ning rever­sal, Democrats claimed the major­i­ty in the Texas House of Representatives for the first time in two decades.

In Ohio, too, Democrats won a U.S. Senate race with for­mer Sen. Sherrod Brown and elect­ed Amy Acton gov­er­nor over for­mer Republican pres­i­den­tial can­di­date Vivek Ramaswamy.

In bat­tle­ground Michigan, all the atten­tion was on the pro­gres­sive Senate can­di­date, Dr. Abdul El-Sayed, but cen­trist Democrat Jocelyn Benson won the gov­er­nor­ship by pro­mot­ing inno­va­tion and entre­pre­neur­ship as engines for eco­nom­ic growth. And, it’s worth not­ing, she won by a land­slide, while El-Sayed bare­ly won, by only 1 percent.

Not only did a mod­er­ate Democrat, for­mer Gov. Roy Cooper, win the Senate race in North Carolina, as expect­ed, but in South Carolina, where no one expect­ed a blue wave, Democrats elect­ed Annie Andrews to the Senate, cap­tured a U.S. House seat, and over­turned 10 seats in the state leg­is­la­ture, break­ing the GOP’s supermajority.

Also, in North Carolina, vot­ers approved con­ser­v­a­tive bal­lot mea­sures to require pho­to IDs for vot­ing and to rein in tax increases.

It should be clear: Americans don’t want a rev­o­lu­tion. They want com­mon­sense policies.

The mes­sage from the heart­land is that peo­ple are hurt­ing because they can’t afford health care, hous­ing, and food. They’re sick of pub­lic cor­rup­tion. They don’t want anoth­er war that goes on and on, demand­ing sac­ri­fices of our young men and women and a big drain on our resources. And they are will­ing to give Democrats a chance, just as they were will­ing to give Republicans a chance two years ago.

Behind that mes­sage, how­ev­er, is a warn­ing: If you mess it up, you can for­get about 2028.


Here in Kentucky, Democrats missed a rare oppor­tu­ni­ty to be part of a nation­al blue wave.

I believe that if Gov. Andy Beshear had done what Cooper did in North Carolina and run for the U.S. Senate instead of hold­ing out for a crowd­ed pres­i­den­tial race that he’s unlike­ly to win, he would have been Kentucky’s senator-elect.

It would also have been more inter­est­ing to watch the two Andys — Beshear and Congressman Andy Barr — com­pete in a nail biter than to watch Barr sav­age the lik­able, but hope­less­ly lib­er­al Charles Booker, for whom the third time was not the charm.

I know, Beshear has said he has no inter­est in being a leg­is­la­tor, that his strength is in exec­u­tive action. But he’s only 48 — the same age Barack Obama was when he became pres­i­dent — so he has time on his side. He could have served a short time in the Senate, as Obama did, and then run for pres­i­dent in 2032.

With nation­al lead­er­ship expe­ri­ence, and a larg­er nation­al pro­file, Beshear would have been a for­mi­da­ble can­di­date six years from now, the kind of Democrat who could win over enough mod­er­ate Republicans and inde­pen­dents to be elect­ed pres­i­dent in what is arguably a cen­ter-right country.

Rocky Adkins, who was a mas­ter­ful leg­is­la­tor as leader of the Kentucky House of Representatives, and who ran a strong sec­ond to Beshear in the 2019 Democratic guber­na­to­r­i­al pri­ma­ry, might also have had a good chance of win­ning against Barr, and prob­a­bly would have been a good senator.

And, as a mem­ber of the new Democratic major­i­ty, he would have had more clout than Barr.

Instead, Adkins and Lt. Gov. Jacqueline Coleman will like­ly bloody each oth­er in the 2027 pri­ma­ry, allow­ing Republican James Comer to stock­pile his mon­ey for the gen­er­al elec­tion and prob­a­bly defeat a bad­ly wound­ed adversary.

Centrist candidate Zach Dembo was the Democrats’ biggest winner in Kentucky in 2026. He flipped a seat in Congress that had been held by Republicans for nearly 14 years. (Randy Patrick)
Centrist can­di­date Zach Dembo was the Democrats’ biggest win­ner in Kentucky in 2026. He flipped a seat in Congress that had been held by Republicans for near­ly 14 years. (Randy Patrick)

The one big win for Democrats in Kentucky was in the con­test for the 6th District of the U.S. House. Zach Dembo, a for­mer fed­er­al pros­e­cu­tor who focused like a laser on the issues of cor­rup­tion and the cost of liv­ing, won the open seat against Republican Dr. Ralph Alvarado of Winchester, whose ear­ly embrace of President Trump didn’t help him in the end.

Dembo is the first Democrat to win the 6th since Ben Chandler, who lost to Barr in 2012. It was a nar­row win; Alvarado won his home coun­ty of Clark and every oth­er coun­ty in the dis­trict except Fayette and Woodford.

I wouldn’t be sur­prised to see a rematch in 2028.


I’ve had sev­er­al peo­ple ask me if I was sur­prised by the out­come of the local elec­tion in Clark County, and I would have to say that for the most part, I wasn’t.

Earlier in the year, I thought the Winchester Board of Commissioners was going to be large­ly made up of young peo­ple with fresh ideas about gov­ern­ing and grow­ing our city. But can­di­date Logan Hall dropped out of the race to become the county’s emer­gency man­age­ment direc­tor, and at the end of the cam­paign, Commissioner Hannah Toole left to become the new tourism direc­tor for Winchester and Clark County.

James Bowman, who ran what I thought was a bril­liant cam­paign, didn’t make the cut, but has already said he will be back in 2028.

The board will have one new com­mis­sion­er, Jim Caldwell, who is well-known as a for­mer WKYT weath­er­man. Since he skipped the debates, it’ll be inter­est­ing to learn what ideas he has for the city and see how he votes as a commissioner.

I wasn’t sur­prised that Circuit Judge Lucy VanMeter won over the appoint­ed incum­bent, Judge Will Moynahan, grand­son of the late fed­er­al judge Bernard Moynahan, in the con­test for the Kentucky Court of Appeals seat in the 5th District, espe­cial­ly in Clark County, where her hus­band, for­mer Supreme Court Chief Justice Larry VanMeter has deep fam­i­ly roots.

What I was sur­prised by, though, was that the judi­cial race was so par­ti­san. Democrat Beshear open­ly sup­port­ed Moynahan, and Kentucky’s Republican leg­isla­tive lead­ers open­ly sup­port­ed VanMeter.

Get the book! "Our Stories, Our Voices: A 5-Year Annioversary Collection."

Judicial races are sup­posed to be non­par­ti­san, and it used to be that can­di­dates were care­ful not to be so obvi­ous about their polit­i­cal affiliation.

Probably the biggest sur­prise of the night for me was in the con­test for the 4th District seat on the Clark County Board of Education. That’s because the win­ner, incum­bent Ben Dorsey, who received more than three quar­ters of all the votes, had just been indict­ed for felony theft along with anoth­er school board mem­ber who was not on the bal­lot this year.

He had been unop­posed when he filed in January, but near the end of the elec­tion, he faced two write-in chal­lengers, Katie Brashear Jones and Valerie Frost.

Granted, Dorsey hasn’t been con­vict­ed of any­thing, and he told me he intends to vig­or­ous­ly defend him­self against the alle­ga­tions. Still, giv­en the fact that he was charged, it sur­pris­es me that he won by so big a margin.

I think it just shows how hard it is for write-in can­di­dates to get many votes when their names aren’t on the bal­lot and elec­tion work­ers can’t give vot­ers the names in writ­ten form to take into the polling place with them when they go to vote.

Please share this story!