Banned book review: Huckleberry Finn

|

Estimated time to read:

1–2 minutes

This title, writ­ten by Mark Twain, is an ear­ly-pub­li­ca­tion-date banned book; first avail­able in 1885, by one month lat­er, it had been banned by, of all peo­ple, librar­i­ans, who decried it as “coarse” and “trash.”

The pro­tag­o­nist, Huck, expe­ri­ences extreme dis­com­fort and annoy­ance at the stric­tures of “polite soci­ety,” so we even­tu­al­ly find him raft­ing the Mississippi River with the run­away slave, Jim.

What fol­lows is a series of adven­tures, mis­ad­ven­tures, and close calls; through Huck’s eyes, we are intro­duced to vil­lains and heroes of vary­ing degrees. We expe­ri­ence the “real world” along with ear­ly-ado­les­cence Huck. The dis­cern­ing read­er will quick­ly see that, sad­ly, not much has changed in the ensu­ing 140 years or so.

Those long-ago cen­so­ri­ous librar­i­ans had anoth­er prob­lem: the ques­tion as to whether or not Huck ever “learns his les­son.” My con­tention is that Mark Twain, with per­haps a big grin, would declare that his pro­tag­o­nist had learned exact­ly what the author had intend­ed all along. The sto­ry is per­haps best under­stood as a polemic on con­for­mi­ty, on soci­etal norms, and on elit­ism in its var­i­ous, some­times sur­pris­ing, forms.

In today’s book-ban­ning cli­mate, this one does not ring the bells of sex­u­al explic­it­ness nor any per­ceived deviance from any per­ceived norm. What remains, then?

Race. Racism rears its head as book-ban­ners react to the use of racial epi­thets; the out­cry at a white child and a black adult male liv­ing and adven­tur­ing togeth­er; at the resent­ment of a run­away slave being por­trayed as more sinned-against than sinning.

This book used to be required read­ing for stu­dents of ado­les­cent years; like many sim­i­lar­ly-assigned titles, I believe it is best under­stood by a mature adult with some life expe­ri­ence behind her. Fifteen-year-old Renee had a very dif­fer­ent opin­ion and under­stand­ing of this book from the way I under­stand it today, a half-cen­tu­ry later.

I rec­om­mend Huckleberry Finn to any­one who enjoys Reconstruction-era fic­tion; south­ern his­tor­i­cal fic­tion; gen­tly humor­ous com­e­dy-of-man­ners fic­tion; or the works of Mark Twain.

Please share this story!